The jewelry industry has a pricing problem. Traditional retail markups of 200-400% mean you're often paying more for the brand name and the shopping experience than for the actual stone and metal. But the alternatives have gotten so good that you no longer have to choose between quality and value.
This guide covers what we've learned about buying fine jewelry at honest prices — whether you're shopping for an engagement ring, a gift, or something for yourself.
The Diamond Markup Problem
Here's a number that might surprise you: a 1-carat diamond engagement ring at a traditional jeweler typically retails for $5,000-10,000. The same ring from an online-first jeweler runs $2,000-4,000. And a visually identical moissanite ring? $300-800.
The markup chain looks like this:
- Mining/manufacturing → wholesale ($800-1,500 for a 1ct diamond)
- Wholesale → retail (+100-200% markup)
- Retail → customer (+100-200% markup again)
Online jewelers like BBBGEM cut out step 3 entirely and reduce step 2, which is how they offer comparable quality at a fraction of the price.
Moissanite: The Smart Alternative
Moissanite has gone from "cheap diamond substitute" to "smart jewelry choice" in about five years. Here's why:
| Property | Diamond | Moissanite |
|---|---|---|
| Hardness (Mohs) | 10 | 9.25 |
| Brilliance (refractive index) | 2.42 | 2.65 (higher = more sparkle) |
| Fire (dispersion) | 0.044 | 0.104 (more rainbow flashes) |
| Price (1ct equivalent) | $3,000-8,000 | $200-600 |
| Durability | Excellent | Excellent |
| Resale value | Poor (50-70% loss) | N/A (not priced for investment) |
The Resale Myth
One argument for diamonds is "resale value." In practice, diamonds lose 50-70% of their retail value the moment you leave the store. Neither diamond nor moissanite is a good investment — they're both purchases, not assets. Buy what looks beautiful to you at a price that doesn't require financing.
What to Look for When Buying Online
Whether you're buying diamond, moissanite, sapphire, or any other stone, here's what matters:
The Stone
- Cut quality matters more than size. A well-cut 0.8ct stone will look better than a poorly-cut 1.2ct stone.
- Color grade — for moissanite, look for DEF (colorless). For diamonds, D-G is the sweet spot where you can't see a difference with the naked eye.
- Clarity — VS1 or better for diamonds. Most moissanite is naturally eye-clean.
The Setting
- Metal type — 14K or 18K gold, or platinum. Avoid gold-plated or vermeil for engagement rings.
- Prong quality — Look for 6-prong settings for round stones (more secure) or bezel settings for active lifestyles.
- Ring sizing — Most online jewelers offer free resizing within a range. Check the policy before ordering.
The Seller
- Return policy — 30 days minimum, no questions asked.
- Certificates — Reputable sellers provide grading certificates for stones over 0.5ct.
- Reviews — Look for specific reviews mentioning durability over time, not just first-impression photos.
BBBGEM: Our Pick for Value Jewelry
BBBGEM is one of our affiliate partners, and they've earned that spot. They specialize in moissanite, lab-grown sapphires, emeralds, and other gemstones in solid gold and platinum settings. Their pricing is transparent (no inflated "compare at" prices), and their reviews consistently highlight quality craftsmanship.
What they're known for:
- Engagement rings (moissanite and gemstone)
- Custom ring designs
- Vintage and art-deco inspired settings
- Lab-grown colored gemstones (sapphire, emerald, alexandrite)
Best for: Anyone ring shopping who values the stone and setting over the brand name.
Weekend deals on things that matter
Curated deals that expire Sunday night. No junk, no spam.
One email per week. No spam. Privacy Policy
